*Data based on RRP (excl. promotions), as checked in March 2025 on the brands' own websites. | Price per 100g calculated as: RRP / (Paper weight per roll x rolls per pack) x 100, as measured in April 2026 | Which? Ratings from Best Toilet Roll review, tested September 2025 and published October 2025

Overall, both brands use 100% bamboo and contribute to more considered choices, with Cheeky Panda scoring higher on comfort and offering stronger value based on like-for-like comparisons.

2. Cheeky Panda vs Who Gives A Crap: Which bamboo toilet paper offers better value for money?

At first glance, Cheeky Panda and Who Gives A Crap can seem similarly priced, especially if you’re comparing pack totals or subscription offers.

But the headline price alone doesn’t tell the full story, and how well a loo roll is going to do for you in the long run. 

What really determines value for money is what you actually get per roll:

• How many sheets

• The size of each sheet

• The ply (thickness)

This all plays into how long each roll lasts in everyday use. And when you compare on that basis, you’ll see... While the headline price looks similar, you may find that while the headline price looks similar, Cheeky Panda provides more paper per pack based on total paper weight comparison, giving you better value over time.

Why “Price Per Roll” or “Price per 100 Sheets” Doesn’t Tell the Full Story

It’s easy to assume that a lower price per pack (or per roll or per 100 sheets) means better value.

But that doesn’t account for differences in:

• Sheet dimensions

• Roll length

• Or overall material per pack

A more accurate way to compare is price per square metre of paper, which reflects how much product you’re actually getting for your money.

On that basis:

• Cheeky Panda comes out lower per 100g than Who Gives A Crap

• Meaning you’re getting more paper for a similar spend

So while WGAC may appear competitive at first glance, the real-world cost is likely to be higher once you factor in total paper per pack.

While these differences might seem minor on paper, they can add up quickly.

Longer rolls mean:

• Fewer roll changes

• Packs lasting longer

• And less frequent reordering

Over time, that can make a noticeable difference to both cost and convenience.

Value Without Compromise

Of course, value isn’t just about quantity. What feels “worth it” also depends on quality. There’s no real benefit to getting more paper if it doesn’t perform well.

That’s where Cheeky Panda aims to strike a balance:

• Strong overall performance

• High comfort levels (as we’ll explore next)

• And efficient use of materials per roll

So rather than choosing between cost and quality, the goal is to deliver both in one brilliant bamboo roll.

Which Bamboo Toilet Paper Is Softer?

When it comes to toilet paper, comfort isn’t a “nice to have”: it’s the thing you notice first.

Independent testing by Which? highlights a noticeable difference here:

• Cheeky Panda: 5/5 for comfort

• Who Gives A Crap: 2/5 for comfort

What the Testing Shows

According to Which?’s independent panel, Cheeky Panda bamboo toilet paper was rated as “exceptionally comfortable”, with testers noting its smooth feel and overall performance.

It performs in line with leading mainstream brands on comfort, while being made from bamboo rather than virgin wood pulp.

WGAC, by comparison, scored lower on comfort in this test, suggesting a different feel that may not suit everyone.

Does Bamboo Mean Compromise?

There’s a common assumption that switching to bamboo toilet paper means giving up some level of softness.

But that’s not necessarily the case. Cheeky Panda’s top ranking (5/5) shows that it’s possible to combine:

• Tree-free tissue

• High comfort

• Reliable everyday performance

Balancing Comfort and Performance

Of course, softness isn’t the only factor. Strength and durability also play a role, and some traditional products may score slightly higher in those areas.

But for most people, comfort is what stands out, and what shapes the overall experience.

So if you’re making the switch to bamboo, it’s worth choosing a product that delivers on softness too.

Packaging Differences: Cheeky Panda vs WGAC

Packaging is easy to overlook but it’s something you interact with every time you open a new roll.

Both Cheeky Panda and Who Gives A Crap avoid plastic packaging, which is a positive step compared to many traditional brands.

But there are some practical differences in how that packaging shows up at home.

Keeping it simple

Cheeky Panda keeps things simple:

• Rolls come in a recyclable cardboard box

• No individual wrapping around each roll

This means less to dispose of once you’ve unpacked your delivery.

WGAC also avoids plastic, but individually wraps their rolls, which adds an extra layer of packaging per roll.

While it can be seen as a fun design feature, it also means additional material you may prefer to avoid.

Everyday Convenience

There’s also a practical side to consider. Without individual wrappers, there’s less time spent unwrapping, less time spent taking each wrapper to the recycling bin, and less overall packaging accumulating in your home.

It’s a small difference, but one that can make day-to-day use feel simpler.

Ultimately, both brands are moving away from plastic, but they take slightly different approaches when it comes to packaging.

Cheeky Panda focuses on minimising packaging overall and keeping things simple and functional, which may be the best choice for you if you’re looking to reduce waste and keep things straightforward at home.

So, Which One Should You Choose?

Both Cheeky Panda and Who Gives A Crap have helped make bamboo toilet paper a more mainstream option, and both offer an alternative to traditional, tree-based tissue.

But when you look at the full picture, some differences may become more important.

From comfort and everyday feel to how long each roll lasts and how the product fits into your routine, the experience isn’t quite the same.

Cheeky Panda stands out for:

• High comfort ratings in independent testing

• More toilet paper per pack, and better value for money

• A simpler, low-fuss approach to packaging 

Better Bamboo Toilet Paper, Without Compromising on What Matters Most

Switching to bamboo doesn’t have to mean making a choice between keeping trees in the forest, softness, and value.

With Cheeky Panda, the aim is to bring those things together in one product, so you don’t need to compromise.

FAQ

Is Cheeky Panda better than Who Gives A Crap?

Cheeky Panda scores higher for comfort (5/5 vs 2/5 in Which? testing) and offers more toilet paper per pack. Both use 100% bamboo (verified by Which?), but Cheeky Panda may suit those prioritising softness, value, and simpler packaging.

Which bamboo toilet paper is the best in the UK?

The best bamboo toilet paper depends on what matters most to you, but independent Which? testing ranks Cheeky Panda highly for comfort (5/5) and overall performance (85%, Best Buy). Comparing factors like softness, roll length, and packaging can help determine the best option for your needs.

Which bamboo toilet paper offers the best value for money?

When it comes to toilet paper, a number of factors impact value for money (such as sheets per roll, ply count and sheet size), as they all change how much toilet paper you use for each wipe. Based on this, Cheeky Panda offers slightly better value than Who Gives A Crap (from £0.48 per 100g vs £0.60 for Who Gives A Crap), meaning more usable paper per pack over time.

Why is bamboo toilet paper more expensive (or is it)?

Bamboo toilet paper can appear more expensive upfront, but the true cost depends on how much paper you get per roll, and how much you need to use for each wipe. When measured by price per m², some bamboo brands offer comparable or better value than traditional or alternative bamboo options.

Is bamboo toilet paper really tree-free?

Bamboo toilet paper is typically made without virgin wood pulp, meaning it doesn’t rely on trees in the same way as traditional toilet paper. Some products, including Cheeky Panda and Who Gives A Crap, have been independently verified as 100% bamboo.

Is bamboo toilet paper as soft as regular toilet paper?

Bamboo toilet paper can be as soft as traditional options, depending on the brand. For example, Cheeky Panda scored 5/5 for comfort in Which? testing, showing that bamboo products can match mainstream softness without using virgin wood pulp.